Various codebreakers have solved thousands of original Enigma messages from World War II over the last few years. Here’s a message of this kind that is still unsolved. Can my readers help?

Breaking original Enigma messages from World War II has been a very active and successful field of research in recent years. One of the pioneers in this field was Jim Gillogly, a reader of this blog, who in 1995 described a new computer-based ciphertext-only attack on Enigma messages.

 

Enigma breaking projects

In later years, the following Enigma breaking projects were realized:

  • Breaking German Wehrmacht Ciphers: In 2004 Frode Weierud and Geoff Sullivan, two more readers of this blog, started a project named “Breaking German Wehrmacht Ciphers“, in the course of which they solved hundreds of original Enigma messages from the Flossenbürg concentration camp and Hitler’s Russia campaign. Last year, Frode Weierud and Olaf Ostwald published a paper titled Modern breaking of Enigma ciphertexts in the scientific magazine Cryptologia. This article reports on further improvements in Enigma codebreaking with modern means.

Frode Weierud (photo used with permission)
  • M4 Message Breaking Project: In 2006 musician Stefan Krah along with hundreds of supporters, who provided computer capacity, broke three cryptograms encrypted with the four-rotor naval Enigma.
  • Breaking German Navy Ciphers: Michael Hörenberg, a teacher from Southern Germany, and Dan Girard (both readers of this blog) have been very successful in breaking Enigma messages, too.

Michael Hörenberg (photo used with permission)

All in all, breaking Enigma messages has made considerable progress in the last 15 years. Not only have computers improved, but Enigma codebreaking algorithms have also become more and more sophisticated.

 

An unsolved message

Wolfgang Schmidt, captain (Hauptmann) at the German armed forces (Bundeswehr) and curator of a Bundeswehr museum in Feldafing near Munich, has now provided me an original Enigma message I hadn’t known before. It was sent on January 10th, 1945. Apparently, the Enigma breaking experts mentioned above have already examined this cryptogram, but it has not been solved yet.

Wolfgang Schmidt told me the following things about this message:

  • The form mentions “Oberbefehlshaber Oberrhein IIA” as the sender. At the time of transmission the “Oberbefehlshaber Oberrhein” (Supreme Commander of Upper Rhine Area) was Heinrich Himmler. “II A” denotes his deputy.
  • The urgency level is “KR BLITZ”. This is unusual, as the highest level was actually “KR”. Apparently, the message was especially urgent.

Before such a message can be attacked with an Enigma codebreaking program, it is necessary to find out which one of the many Enigma variants was used. It seems very likely that in this case it was a Wehrmacht Enigma (the most common Enigma type). Does a reader know more (I have to admit that I am not an expert of Enigma types)?

If you know something about the background of this message or if you can even solve it, please leave a comment.


Further reading: The machine that broke the Enigma

Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/groups/13501820
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/763282653806483/

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Gib Deine E-Mail-Adresse an, um diesen Blog zu abonnieren und Benachrichtigungen über neue Beiträge via E-Mail zu erhalten.

Kommentare (5)

  1. #1 Michael BGNC
    Lake Constance
    8. Januar 2019

    I will start an attempt tomorrow. But under 100 letters, my hillclimber is a little bit weak. So I guess Dan G. , Olaf O. , Frode W. or George L. will have more success or at least be faster.

    Michael
    (BGNC)

  2. #2 Dan Girard
    8. Januar 2019

    I’ll give it a try, as well. A few of the letters are a little hard to read, though. Michael and Klaus, does this transcription look right to you?

    Indicators: BIQ RST

    Ciphertext:
    HITLU TSUNQ RTLIA BFTQR
    NUWLQ VNITR SETNQ IPKLM
    AHEEF DCABC UWORU BSWYX
    BGGFD TXCBX DVDUC EZGFB
    KYILX OWNPQ RTUVS WM

    Dan Girard

  3. #3 Richard Bean
    Brisbane
    8. Januar 2019

    The first stage is reading it 😉

    To me it looks like

    hiqrst

    hitlu tsunq rtlia bftqr
    nuwlq vnitr setnq ipklm
    aheef dcabe uworu bswya
    bggfd txcbx dvduc ezgfb
    kyilx awnpq rtuvs wm

  4. #4 Michael BGNC
    Lake Constance
    9. Januar 2019

    Hi Dan

    I confirm your reading:

    HITLU TSUNQ RTLIA BFTQS
    NUWLQ VNITR SETVQ IPKLM
    AHEEF DCABC UWORU BSWYX
    BGGFD TXCBX DVDUC EZGFB
    KYILX OWNPQ RTUVS WM

    All the best

    Michael

  5. #5 Michael
    9. Januar 2019

    I don’t understand anything about enigma messages, but because I read the BFTQ*S* of the comment above very clearly as BFTQ*R*, and have also deviations to all other transcriptions posted so far, here is my transcription 🙂

    2003-97-HIQRST
    HITLU TSUNQ RTLIA BFTQR
    NUWLQ VNITR SETNQ IPKLM
    AHEEF DCABC UWORU BSWYA
    BGGFD TXCBX DVDUC EZGFB
    KYILX AHNPQ RTUVS WM

    All the best
    Michael