In Nature erscheint heute ein Essay ArXiv at 20 von ArXiv-Gründer Paul Ginsparg.

Das ArXiv hatte noch in der Vor-Web-Ära begonnen als ein Preprint-Archiv, dessen Abonnenten über die e-Mail-Adresse hep-th@xxx.lanl.gov automatisch bei Neuerscheinungen informiert wurden. Gedacht war ursprünglich an ca. 100 Artikel pro Jahr und die Preprints sollten nur für 3 Monate gespeichert werden.

i-5c2e826ecff4acffb53e16dab5fea93c-476145a-i2.0.jpg

Inzwischen werden ca. 75000 Artikel pro Jahr gespeichert.
In dem Nature-Artikel gibt Ginsparg nun bekannt, daß das ArXiv künftig komplett von der Universitäts-Bibliothek Cornell administriert wird

For me, the repository was supposed to be a three-hour tour, not a life sentence. ArXiv was originally conceived to be fully automated, so as not to scuttle my research career. But daily administrative activities associated with running it can consume hours of every weekday, year-round without holiday. So, from September, the site will be entirely in the hands of the staff of Cornell University Library in Ithaca, New York. I will remain on the advisory board and continue some research projects in text and data mining and in supporting next-generation document formats and information filters.

und nutzt den Anlaß für Reflektionen über das ArXiv und Themen wie Qualitätskontrolle, Finanzierung und Integration neuer Werkzeuge.

In einem historischen Abriß berichtet er zunächst über die Vorreiterrolle des ArXiv bei vielen technologischen Entwicklungen und meint “building the technology was simpler than managing the sociological and financial aspects”. Ein Teil der Finanzierung des ArXiv erfolgt über die Anfang letzten Jahres diskutierte freiwillige Kostenbeteiligung von Universitäts-Instituten, ein längerfristiges Geschäftsmodell existiert aber bisher nicht.

Und er diskutiert natürlich die anstehenden Entwicklungen: manche Nutzer hätten gerne Kommentarstränge zu den einzelnen Preprints, aber das Administrieren solcher Diskussion wäre sehr aufwändig. Aus dem selben Grund wird es kein konventionelles Peer-review geben:

Even the minimal filtering of incoming preprints to maintain basic quality control involves significant daily administrative activity. Incoming abstracts are given a cursory glance by volunteer external moderators for appropriateness to their subject areas; and various automated filters, including a text classifier, flag problem submissions. Although the overall rate of such submissions is well below 1%, they tend to cluster in specific areas (such as general relativity, quantum mechanics and unified theories in physics; proofs of the Riemann hypothesis, Goldbach’s conjecture and new proofs of Fermat’s last theorem in mathematics; P versus NP problem in computer science).

Und er diskutiert natürlich auch das Thema traditioneller vs. Online-Zeitschriften:

The transition to article formats and features better suited to modern technology than to print on paper has also been surprisingly slow. Page markup formats, such as PDF, have only grudgingly given way to XML-based ones that support features such as manipulable graphics, dynamic views, linked annotations and semantic markup. Part of this caution is a result of the understandable need to maintain a stable archive of research literature, as provided by paper over centuries.

Ginsparg: “ArXiv at 20”, Nature Volume: 476, Pages: 145-147

Kommentare (4)

  1. #1 Gucci
    30. November 2011

    E ‘bene per voi di acquistare Scarpe Gucci borse del progettista è di avere abbastanza soldi. Ed è anche non male per voi di scegliere replica borse Gucci è si è in budget limitato. Gucci Borse Si dovrebbe capire che non troverete molta differenza tra un autentico e replica uno perché sono tutti accessorio di moda e possono aggiungere stile al tuo vestito che si trasformano in ulteriori e più alla moda ed eccezionali. Infine, vogliE ‘bene per voi di acquistare Scarpe Gucci borse del progettista è di avere abbastanza soldi. Ed è anche non male per voi di scegliere replica borse Gucci è si è in budget limitato. Gucci Borse Si dovrebbe capire che non troverete molta differenza tra un autentico e replica uno perché sono tutti accessorio di moda e possono aggiungere stile al tuo vestito che si trasformano in ulteriori e più alla moda ed eccezionali. Infine, voglio dire che anche voi credere alle mie parole – Gucci potrebbe essere il beniamino della moda quando si scopre qualche cosa moda e Gucci.

    Borse di Gucci hanno una storia di sofisticazione eccellenti e per molto di più di 80 anni. Con una gamma incredibile di disegni e guarda, Borse Gucci c’è una borsa di Gucci per adattarsi a qualsiasi tendenza di moda. Molto più importante, borsa di Gucci è popolare con il vecchio e giovane, Gucci Outlet , e accettata da un sacco di un popolo.o dire che anche voi credere alle mie parole – Gucci potrebbe essere il beniamino della moda quando si scopre qualche cosa moda e Gucci.

    Borse di Gucci hanno una storia di sofisticazione eccellenti e per molto di più di 80 anni. Con una gamma incredibile di disegni e guarda, Borse Gucci c’è una borsa di Gucci per adattarsi a qualsiasi tendenza di moda. Molto più importante, borsa di Gucci è popolare con il vecchio e giovane, Gucci Outlet , e accettata da un sacco di un popolo.

  2. #2 ugg outlet
    10. Dezember 2011

    b.You might think that your prints can do without a coating. But you must understand that it is in fact important for the quality of your prints. c.Coatings provide your prints with a protective layer that prolongs its life. This means that it lengthens the capacity of your prints to survive through various factors such as moist and water. When your prints have protective coatings, it makes it more durable through touch conditions. d.UV coating , for instance Louis Vuitton Leather , makes your prints fade resistant and water resistant – two of the most important prolonging characteristic that your prints may have. 3.You can print a few pieces using your office printer but when your business calls for a large number of prints louis vuitton women low shoes, a printing company will be the best option for you. a.As you increase in the number of prints , the more expensive it becomes if you are using a personal printer. But if you opt to choose a printing company that can do this for you Burberry Sling Bag , the principle become wholesale: the more you order , the more you save. 4.Without an online printing company to provide all your needs in printing UGG Big Kids Boots, you may find it hard to actually produce the kind of prints that you want. a.For example , if you want prints that are folded UGG Classic Bailey Button 5803 ABC, you may find it hard to score your prints in the right way. You need the right equipment to score your prints Fashion Ugg Big Kids Ultimate 5275 ADR, especially if they are many.b.If your prints are multipage , and you need to bind them Ugg Knit Cardy, you would need a production just to accomplish a hundred prints. Do not spend for time or energy doing this when you can attend to other matters. Printing companies offer finishing jobs such as these.c.You might think that you can personally score or bind your prints , but this is can only be done in a few prints. If your needs are large in number, which is most likely to be Ugg Classic Bailey Button Bomber, doing this by yourself will almost be impossible. For you not to have a hard time with your prints Louis Vuitton Women Sneakers, contact an online printing company now that can take that extra burden off your shoulders.
    Links removed

  3. #3 monster beats
    29. März 2012

    Die Eltern geben ihr perücke echthaar letztes Geld, leihen sich zusätzliches etwas von Verwandten undbeats by dre vertrauen ihre Kinder den Schleppern an. Die sind international vernetzt und verdienen am Kinderhandel Millionen. Manche Kinder ergreifen auch selbst die Initiative, um dem Elend in ihrer Heimat zu entkommen. In Deutschland müssen sie und ihrebeats by dre reduziert Betreuer um Rechte kämpfen, die ihnen eigentlich von der UN garantiert sind, aber selten Anwendung finden. Flüchtlingskinder leben mit einer Duldung. Das heißt, sie können jederzeit abgeschoben werden. Pöppel sagt, dass alle Angst davor haben. Ein junger Flüchtling in ihrem Haus ugg boots sale sei aufgrund der Unsicherheit hochgradig suizidgefährdet und bräuchte dringend einen Therapieplatz.
    Siegfried Pöppel berichtet auch von all den bürokratischen Hindernissen, die den Alltag belasten: Wenn zum Beispiel die Bankenwindows 7 product key sich weigern, geduldeten Jugendlichen ein Konto zu eröffnen. Wenn Betriebe junge Flüchtlinge ausbilden wollen, aber das rigorose Ausländergesetz dies nicht erlaubt. „Was ist, wenn sie irgendwann allein zurechtkommen müssen, wenn die Jugendhilfe nicht mehr zuständig ist? Wie werden sie umgehen mit dem alltäglichen Rassismus in beats by dre Deutschland?“, fragt Pöppel. Das sind Sorgen, über die bei „Wege ins Leben“ offen gesprochen wird. Und was gibt den Jugendlichen die Kraft zum Weiterleben? monster beats „Manchmal ist es die Religion“, meint Angelika Binias. „Dann sagen sie: Ich habe alles verloren, meine Eltern, meine Heimat, ich weiß nicht, wer ich eigentlich bin, aber ich glaube an einen Gott, dem ich mich anvertrauen kann, egal wo ich bin.“ Vor kurzem hat eine junge monster beats Afrikanerin, die Pöppel lange betreut hat, mit beats by dre reduziert ihrem dreijährigen Sohn in Dahlem vorbeigeschaut. Und sich noch einmal für alle Hilfe bedankt.

    Spam links removed.

  4. #4 replica watches
    10. Mai 2012