Apparently, the silk dress cryptogram is based on a codebook that contained codewords like Cairo, Missouri, and Concordia (the one shown above contains meaningless expressions like egost, egotu, egouv and similar). To solve such a cryptogram it is usually necessary to have access to the codebook.
In 2014 I wrote a blog article (in German) about the silk dress cryptogram. I received many interesting comments, but no solution.
For instance, Steve Bellovin, a renowned codebook expert, wrote (a code is in this case the same as a codebook):
My first assumption is that it’s an ordinary commercial code. The style is certainly consistent with 1880s telegraph codes. On the first one, I even see a repeated three-word sequence: ‘new johnson none’. You may want to point folks at https://books.google.com/books?id=-7NLAAAAYAAJ as an example of what a commercial code of that era looks like. The trick will likely be figuring out which book it was; there were many. (Also, the marginal numbers are definitely word counts for that line; telegraph companies charged by the word.) Finally, people often interpolated plaintext words with codebooks, especially folks who weren’t accustomed to codebooks and for words not listed. If one of the telegrams is about the dress, the repeated word “lining” might make sense that way.
Here is my summary of all the comments that went in:
- The message is probably a telegram (or it even consists of several telegrams).
- The words of the message were probably taken from an 1880’s codebook. Here is an example: https://www.jmcvey.net/cable/miller_1882_p54_detail_700w339h.jpg
- The numbers between the lines are word counts (telegraph companies charged by the word).
- The marginals (e.g. “11:30 PM”) probably indicate the time when the respective telegram was sent or received. If this is the case the message might consist of three telegrams.
Can a reader find out more? Can the codebook that was used be identified? If so, please let me know.
Follow @KlausSchmeh
Further reading: How FBI codebreakers found out what “K1, P2, CO8, K5, P2” means
Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/groups/13501820
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/763282653806483/
Kommentare (6)